*Recently, questions have been raised about some of the results of a lab test on Dr. Elsey’s cat food. This lab report is currently being reviewed and verified, and additional clarifications will be released following analysis by a 3rd party.
This brand has earned its keep in the cat litter department, but is Dr. Elsey’s cat food worthy of your cat’s bowl? Read our unbiased Dr. Elsey’s cat food review to find out.
The Cats.com Standard—Rating Dr. Elsey’s on What Matters
We’ve analyzed Dr. Elsey’s and graded it according to the Cats.com standard, evaluating the brand on species-appropriateness, ingredient quality, product variety, price, customer experience, and recall history. Here’s how it rates in each of these six key areas.
Ratings
- Species-Appropriateness – 9/10
- Ingredient Quality – 7/10
- Product Variety – 6/10
- Price – 5/10
- Customer Experience – 9/10
- Recall History – 10/10
Overall Score: 7.7/10
We give Dr. Elsey’s cat food a 46 out of 60 rating or a B+ grade.
About Dr. Elsey’s
Back in 1989, a feline-only veterinarian named Dr. Bruce Elsey started selling cat litter. The company’s since become a household name, producing a large variety of affordable, effective products for your litter box.
In 2017, the company took its first step outside of the litter box and launched a line of cat food. The line is called cleanprotein™, a name promising highly-digestible, efficient food that fuels your carnivore as nature intended.
Sourcing and Manufacturing
Dr. Elsey’s cat food is manufactured in the United States from ingredients sourced around the world. The company sources proteins from the United States and obtains other ingredients from Europe and Canada.
Dr. Elsey’s doesn’t source any primary ingredients from China, but may use China-sourced taurine.
NOTE: Throughout 2021 and into 2022, Dr. Elsey’s experienced significant product shortages and delays in the distribution of their cleanprotein™ line of kibble and paté. In an update posted on the brand’s website, the manufacturer linked the issue to industry-wide issues with supply, labor, and transportation.
As of the spring of 2023, these issues do not seem to have been completely resolved yet. Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein™ chicken and salmon dry food recipes – along with most canned food formulas – are more regularly available, but the duck, rabbit, and turkey recipes are still frequently out of stock.
Has Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food Been Recalled?
It doesn’t appear that Dr. Elsey’s cat food has ever been recalled.
What Kinds of Cat Food Does Dr. Elsey’s Offer?
Dr. Elsey’s offers a modest selection of wet and dry cat food.
The five dry cat food formulas stand out with exceptionally low carbohydrate content. All five recipes are made with at least 93% animal protein and only contain around 10% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis. Unlike most kibble, Dr. Elsey’s dry food is made without the use of grains and other starchy ingredients and instead relies on gelatin as a binder.
The current cleanprotein dry food lineup from Dr. Elsey’s includes five recipes. The original chicken recipe is the only single-protein formula Dr. Elsey’s offers – the other four dry foods all contain dried chicken in addition to the primary protein source which is either turkey, duck, salmon, or rabbit. All recipes aside from the chicken formula also contain pork protein isolate as a concentrated source of species-appropriate animal protein.
Dr. Elsey’s wet food is less groundbreaking, but sticks to carnivorous dietary principles with high meat inclusions, moderate fat content, and minimal carbohydrate content.
With single source duck and pork recipes along with a selection of mixed-protein foods including ocean whitefish, beef, salmon, rabbit & turkey, chicken, and duck & turkey, the Dr. Elsey’s wet food lineup is small but diverse.
Dr. Elsey’s cat food is never made with by-products and doesn’t use mystery proteins like animal by-products or meat meal. The foods never contain artificial ingredients, including artificial colors, flavors, or chemical preservatives that could harm your cat over time.
Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food – Top 3 Recipes Reviewed
Product Name | Food Type | Primary Protein | Calories | Price | Our Grade |
Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Chicken Formula Grain-Free Dry Cat Food | Dry | Chicken | 115 kcal/oz. | $0.39 per lb | A- |
Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Salmon Formula Grain-Free Dry Food | Dry | Salmon | 115 kcal/oz. | $0.39 per oz | A- |
Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Chicken Formula Grain-Free Canned Food | Wet | Chicken | 36 kcal/oz. | $0.47 per oz | A |
What Do Customers Think of Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food?
Most customers like Dr. Elsey’s cat food, though a few say their cats didn’t enjoy it or noted that it was out of their price range. Here’s what a few real customers have to say about it:
Positive Reviews
“My cat who is extremely picky when it comes to dry food just loves this one. The ingredients are great & I love that it comes in a 2 lb bag so that my cat can eat the entire bag before it gets stale; he refuses to eat dry food which has been opened too long no matter how tightly it is resealed & usually I wind up with an abundance left over but not with this one. Good to the last bite!” – Mary55, reviewing Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Chicken Formula Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
“My 13 year old cat was diagnosed with diabetes and prescribed Glyco Balance by Royal Canine. He would not eat he canned food at all but would eat the dry if I mixed with another food. After some researco`h I found Dr Elseys and he loves the canned and dry food. BONUS: he went into remission in just 2 weeks and is back to his old sassy, demanding self. I will say that 2 weeks is unusual it not unheard of, dependeds on the cats overall health, care and diet.” – Sopicky, reviewing Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Turkey Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
Negative Reviews
“I have 4 cats. All ranging from, “I’ll eat anything ” to “nah, I don’t think so”. I also only feed wet food having researched cat health and proper feeding. I was feeding Wellness cat food with no issues, but when I stumbled upon Dr. Elseys Cleanprotein I was doubly excited! Ingredients are amazing so I gave it a try. I ordered a case of the Turkey. Visually it looks appealing and smells good. Texture wise it’s very mushy. All 4 cats will not eat it! I tried tough love and like a mom I thought, “you’ll eat what I put down”. 2 days later and still no eating but lots of stares and crying, I gave in. I’m sad to have to give 1 star, but the reality is they do not like it, not even my non-picky boy. Back to Wellness.” – Daisybd, reviewing Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Turkey Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
“I love Dr. Elsey’s products; however, this price is really ridiculous for pet lovers who have a multi-cat household. I strive to feed my cats the best possible grain free food, but Dr. Elsey’s cat food prices are super high for a very small bag. Like the food, but too expensive for pet owners who have more than one cat. Dissatisfied and surprised! No thanks!” – CatLady, reviewing Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein Salmon Formula Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
How Much Does Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food Cost?
Dr. Elsey’s cleanprotein dry cat food ranges from about $0.35 to $0.40 per ounce. It’s similarly priced to Young Again cat food and offers similar nutritional benefit in being low in carbohydrate and high in animal protein. To feed the average 10-pound cat Dr. Elsey’s dry food, it would cost between $0.60 and $0.80 per day.
The cost of Dr. Elsey’s wet cat food is higher. This is pretty common for brands that offer both wet and dry food. To feed a 10-pound cat cleanprotein wet food, it would cost about $2.61 per day.
Overall, Is Dr. Elsey’s a Good Choice?
Dr. Elsey’s offers some of the best dry cat food on the market. It’s rich in animal protein and made without animal by-products for maximum bioavailability. At less than 5% starch on a dry matter basis, Dr. Elsey’s foods won’t spike blood sugar and may even be appropriate for diabetic cats.
Their wet foods are less extraordinary, but they stand out, too. They’re comparable to top brands like Hound & Gatos, Ziwi Peak, and other high-protein paté-style foods. They offer a rich combination of muscle meat and organs along with multiple sources of omega-3 fatty acids.
This brand shines as a starting point for recovering kibble addicts. If you’re transitioning your cat off his high-carbohydrate dry diet, Dr. Elsey’s is a great intermediate stage between traditional kibble and a truly species-appropriate diet.
Where To Buy Dr. Elsey’s Cat Food?
You can buy Dr. Elsey’s online through Amazon, Chewy, PetSmart, Petco, Jet, Homes Alive Pets, and PetFlow.com. Use the company’s store locator to find a retailer near you.
I have been feeding my cats Dr. Elsey’s for 2 years and I love it because it has the highest protein content most similar to real prey, which is close to 60% for most prey species including rodents (I found a cool document from a zoo on nutritional analysis of live prey which they feed their animals). But I am dismayed to see the CYANIDE detected by the lab in your analysis report. There are no units on it. Can you please provide more information from the lab? Should I be worried about this?
Hey Kathryn, that’s a really good question, but unfortunately, I don’t have much context on it, myself. I just sent an email to our lab and will see if I can shed some light on the issue. Thank you for asking.
Hi Mallory,
Is there any update on this? That is so concerning.
I haven’t heard back from our lab, Maja. I’m sorry!
I want to try feeding my cat the chicken dry kibble, but I’m a tad worried about the recent amazon and chewy reviews complaining of the kibble being smashed and crumbling in the bag before they even open it, did this ever come up for you or has it since?
I haven’t tried it in a couple of years, so, unfortunately, I can’t comment on this. However, it does seem to be a real issue, and I would not be surprised if you encountered it upon purchasing. Fortunately, Chewy is quite generous with refunds, and you may be able to get your money back if there is a real problem.
Hi there! I have now bought a few bags since reading the reviews about the smashed kibble, and while I had one bag that was very crumbly, the past two bags have not had the issue. I’d say it seems to have been corrected.
Thanks for sharing. 🙂
I ordered some in January and it was fine.
I bought a bag last week and the ingredients have changed. First four ingredients are chicken, dried egg product, gelatin, chicken fat. No pork listed. Here is the current product that is being sold: https://www.drelseys.com/products/chicken-recipe/
Thanks for bringing this to our attention, Stacy! We’ll take a closer look and get this review updated.
Any news on that Cyanide found in the food, or you all will just play it by ear and hope everyone forgets about it.
I understand is not your fault, but maybe another private lab analysis using a different lab?
Hey, I just haven’t heard back from the lab and haven’t had a chance to look into it further. I’ll contact the company for more information as well. Sorry about the late reply!
Hi Mallory, any news on the Cyanide that was detected? My kibble loving kitties love Dr Elsey’s kibbles and there really isn’t another low carb alternative that they like so I am very concerned. Thanks in advance for any updates you can offer!
Hi Maggie, I’m still in conversations with Dr. Elsey’s and the lab. It’s worth noting that cyanide is expected in foods containing flaxseed, and flaxseed meal sold in the human food market can safely have up to 250 mg/kg cyanide, which is significantly higher than what we’re seeing here. Furthermore, I’ve been told that the testing method the lab used may have not been appropriate for this food type. Overall, I would not be too concerned by the presence of cyanide here, but I can’t give you any solid information just yet.
A lot of the reviews are saying the quality of this food dropped and that their cats are getting sick 🙁
My kitten has been eating it since September & definitely no illness. He has never even had a hair ball or thrown up as far as we know. Very happy with it. I feel our cats should consume dry food enough so they will eat it while boarded or most importantly when we are gone. I don’t have cat sitters feed raw. I just prefer not to. His diet is 90% moist raw & canned. So far perfectly shaped kibble. No crumbles or dust. I buy thru Amazon.
Thanks for sharing your experience, Angela.
You are most welcome. I have recommended this food & your website to family & I see my brother left a comment. How funny!
🙂 A family of dedicated cat enthusiasts! Love it!
I found Dr. Elsey’s about a year ago. My cat (whom passed away last month, NOT from eating this food) absolutely loved this food – both salmon and chicken formulas. She was a picky eater, so when she approved, I was delighted.
I adopted a kitten in June 2022, started her on Dr. Elsey’s in September – she loves it as well.
Now…we’ve added a 6 month old kitten to our family, he too, loves this food. We add bone broth to it and always provide wet food for the majority of their meals.
I am concerned with reading about the Cyanide and someone posted about cats getting sick from this food. I’d really like to know more about this…very concerning!!
Am I missing something? I just may be missing it but I don’t see chickpeas listed on the blue bag ingredient list above. Under cons it says some cats may not tolerate peas well or something to that effect but I don’t think the chicken recipe has peas in it. By all means double check. I just got new glasses & my apology If I just can’t see we’ll enough. lol. My kitten is fed homemade wet food but we do leave this out for him & he definitely eats it. Seems to enjoy the crunch & his bowel movements are small with very little odor. His homemade food is very moist. I like knowing If he is hungry he has food present. He will eat the dogs food if we don’t leave out some dry kibble & with this being so very inexpensive & with better ingredients than most we are so thankful you presented the info. I would have never have found this without your website. Thank you. The bag is so plain & not flashy so easily overlooked. I purchased 10 bags & 3 bags in & as of Christmas of 2022 the kibble is formed & not dusty nor crumbly. Happy New Year! 🙂
Btw, I purchased using Amazon starting in September & it’s now Christmas 2022.
Any updates on the Cyanide? It’s been quite a few months.
No, I haven’t heard anything back from the lab, but I have reached out to someone at the Dr. Elsey’s food formulation partner, and they may be able to help.
Maybe I’m stating the obvious, and/or maybe it’s already been pointed out, but where there’s flaxseed, there is most often cyanide.
It is odd that lab report does not list the units. Based on the article (linked below), I’m wondering if it is in mg?
As stated in the article, it is good and necessary for consumers to ask questions of manufacturers, and any manufacturer that does not get back to the consumer about their concerns might not deserve our patronage. Hopefully a response will come soon, since the product does seem to be one of the better ones based on the protein content in their dry food.
I’m no good at math as it is, so can’t do much with the information given in the article. But without knowing the units used to measure the cyanide present in this food, it’s impossible to do anything.
https://www.nutraceuticalalliance.ca/post/ground-flaxseed-how-much-can-we-and-our-companion-animals-safely-eat
I agree; I’ve tried to get more information from the lab, but it’s been a struggle. Still working on getting this sorted out. Thank you.
The article provided in the original posts states “It is likely that all known commercial dog and cat foods or supplements containing ground flaxseed should not be of any concern to the pet owner or veterinarian.” The article also states “Scientists have developed ways of treating flaxseed to prevent cyanide production” along with “Ground flaxseed is widely used in pet foods, as well as in veterinary health products and various types of supplements” Im not a scientist or a vet, just logical. If this article is saying all of these things, I think it’s safe to assume that the cyanide found in the food is a safe for a cat. If it weren’t, the product would have gotten recalled. I can imagine this isn’t the only test run to ever have been done on the food. Im not familiar with all of the cat foods cats.com has sent to labs, but I can also imagine this isn’t the only food they’ve tested with cyanide present, judging by what the article linked says.
I like their chicken kibble but I’m also worried about the cyanide content. Was it specifically the chicken kibble that got tested? I’m worried about purchasing again without knowing exactly how much is in it. I don’t want hurt my cats over time. If the report did not show cyanide this would be the best catfood out there. Some enlightenment in this issue would be great.
Unfortunately, I can’t help much at this time. Our lab has not been of help; we still don’t have units for the cyanide measurement, and the method used to detect cyanide may not have been appropriate for the food type, which also calls everything into question. I apologize for the slow flow of information—still trying to figure it out.
I saw there was a reply to my question on the Cyanide issue, but my comment is gone. I noticed Costco lab report has the same issue, traces of cyanide but no metrics. I think anything with flaxseed will have traces of cyanide, but it would be really nice to know the metircs. I contacted Dr. Elsey’s, they assured me their food is safe and meets standards. I bought another bag since Costco has sold a ton of their food for years and there have never been recalls for cyanide issues concerning flaxseed in cat food. I think it’s safe, but still metrics would be nice and also knowing or having an idea of the sample size they detected it in as well. If some people leave food out or a cat gets into the dry food bag, there’s a concern that if the cat eats too much, can the cat get poisoned by the food?
I’m surprise your 2023 update doesn’t mentioned anything about Dr Elsey’s supply issues. They been out of rabbit kibble since last summer. And the chicken and salmon kibble seems different because now my cat won’t eat it.
Lining this up for an update. Thank you!
Update: I’m still buying Dr. Elseys dry food online & Im also not finding dusty crumbles in the bags. Just thought I’d update that & my cat still loves it moistened & without bone broth. 3-1-23
Mallory is there any update on the cyanide? I stated feeding this food to my cat based off your video. I have been very happy w/ it but never knew about the cyanide issue. Seems that people have been asking about this for over a year now there surely must be some new information?
Hi Jason, thanks for the comment. I wouldn’t be too worried. I’m still in conversations with Dr. Elsey’s and the lab, so I can’t give you a final answer, but we do know a few things. One, it was confirmed that the units were supposed to be mg/kg, but our report was misprinted. I’ve chased after the lab and should be getting a corrected copy soon, and we’ll replace it on the site. It’s worth noting that cyanide is expected in foods containing flaxseed, and flaxseed meal sold in the human food market can safely have up to 250 mg of cyanide per kg, which is significantly higher than what we’re seeing here. Furthermore, I’ve been told that the testing method the lab used may have not been appropriate for this food type, meaning that the presence of other compounds in the food may be inflating the perceived cyanide content. Overall, I would not be too concerned by the presence of cyanide here, but I can’t give you a complete answer yet. Apologies for the confusion and long wait.